You Want Challenging Days for the Next Few Months?
Near the end of December, the sun will rise in Calgary at about 9:37. In some schools, first period will be wrapping up just as the sun starts cutting through the darkness. Under Alberta Time, the school bell rings at the same time on the wall clock, but it rings an hour earlier by the sun than it did last winter. What does that look like in your classroom? Students have made it to their desks and you’re ready to teach. Some of those brains sitting in chairs are still in sleep mode. Alberta’s new time system (ABT) | Alberta.ca
Two things are at work here. First, sleep. Alberta Time pushes the clock an hour ahead relative to the sun. The alarm rings at the usual time, but biologically it is an hour earlier. Compounding this, adolescents already drift toward later bedtimes with puberty. The outcome: teens arrive at school with less rest. Second, morning daylight provides that essential natural "go" signal to reset the body clock, driving alertness and learning readiness. This winter in Calgary, the first period wraps up right as sunrise hits. We are asking young minds to engage before receiving that sunlight activation. Body clock reset and mind activation get delayed, leaving outcomes to be determined.
Pile that imposed sleep-disruption onto a developing brain. The developing prefrontal cortex is there to help students navigate what is asked of them throughout the day. Hold the instructions in mind. Stay with the lesson when something distracting is happening two desks over. Pause to think about what will happen if you say the first thing that comes to mind. Those are executive functions, and they are in development through the preteen and teen years. The point is, expect that more students will now find it a little more challenging with a biological clock that is so out of sync with the social wall clock. Executive function may look more like mild dysfunction at times. The December/January reality of an externally imposed sleep disruption where the social clock and the sun clock are so out of sync is going to present new challenges that can be managed. . A canonical trajectory of executive function maturation from adolescence to adulthood | Nature Communications
So we come around to solutions: Here’s my best swing at what is being pitched at us (in the dark of morning): Two evidence supported, quick interventions that will help. Recommendation #1: A five- to seven-minute exercise snack starting the first class, one that gets the big muscles moving and fully engaged. Fifteen minutes best but seven will do. Recommendation #2: Once the sun is up, break out for a quick five minute “walk and talk” outside, even on cloudy days. This is totally about sunlight triggering the biological clock, not exercise… It is the important one that determines activation neurobiologically and metabolically. That will give the body clock its morning “go” signal and kick an otherwise shite start to the day off in a good way. Systematic review of acute physically active learning and classroom movement breaks on children’s physical activity, cognition, academic performance and classroom behaviour: understanding critical design features | BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine
The Research
Executive function is in development in teens; using it depends on the sleep
First, a little on neurobiology 101. The prefrontal cortex is central to executive function. It helps students focus, pick up the thread of a lesson after a distraction, and pause to consider their options before responding. From the preteen years into adulthood, the prefrontal cortex is still maturing and its connections with other parts of the brain are still developing. Education counts on those connections from the first bell. This year, under Alberta Time, that bell rings an hour earlier by the sun than it did last winter. For months, students will start school in darker mornings, and in midwinter some will be well into their second class before they get a glimpse of daylight. That’s a problem for education. The earlier start, the darker start delays early exposure to that morning light blast that reset the biological body clock. . There are some concerns about what this may mean for students’ mental health and well-being. We’re asking a lot of a teenage brain. We will have to watch and see and take measure to protect them.
www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-42540-8
https://www.timeanddate.com/sun/canada/calgary?month=12
Sleep restriction worsens mood and emotion regulation in adolescents - PMC
Alberta’s new time system (ABT) | Alberta.ca
https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/the-teen-brain-7-things-to-know
Decision-making in the adolescent brain | Nature Neuroscience
Short sleep makes it harder to stay with a lesson
When adolescents face sleep disruptions, there is an attention lapse important to understand. These brief lapses happen repeatedly for a few seconds at a time. These lapses involve microsleeps, “nodding off” without the nodding, that is they happen while the student is still awake, “lights on but nobody home”. It is ever so brief, but before it happens there is a period of non-processessing. In a simulated classroom study, they set teens up to study this, teens were less attentive and scored lower on lesson quizzes after several short nights. A few seconds sounds like very little. Across a morning, though, repeatedly losing focus means taking in less of what’s being taught, best described as brief attention lapses. These phenomena are most prevalent in early morning classrooms. My concern is what are we to expect form learning in the coming months. Attention, learning, and arousal of experimentally sleep-restricted adolescents in a simulated classroom - PubMed
Short sleep makes it harder to let things go
Baum and colleagues tested 50 teens aged 14 to 17 after five nights with six and a half hours in bed and again after five nights with ten hours in bed. After the shorter nights, teens were more irritable and had more difficulty regulating their emotions. Interesting is hyperactivity and impulsivity scores showed no clear change. But in a Canadian experiment with children aged 7 to 11, teachers who were unaware of how the children’s sleep had been changed reported differences in emotional volatility and impulsivity. Another teen experiment found a stronger reaction to negativism after a short night, but students could still use a taught strategy to rethink how they were seeing a situation. Taken together, these findings support observations known to any teacher, “sleepless in Seattle means more issues in the classroom.”. Sleep restriction worsens mood and emotion regulation in adolescents - PMC
The winter clock brings first period earlier relative to sunrise
To recap: Morning light does two jobs. It helps keep the body clock in step with the day, and it can help us feel more alert soon after we get it. In the morning it is kind of like our lift off signal to get started. That’s the morning “go” signal we’re talking about. Timing matters. Light in the evening tends to shift the body clock later, not good for optimal learning in the morning, while light at the right time in the morning resets the body clock to align with that day’s scheduled activities. What changes under Alberta Time is when students may get their first full daylight, it is well into their school day. BUT this has to be organized. For students who used to get it on the way to school or around the first bell, it now comes later in the school morning and this is the problem we face for two to three months this school year.
School Start Times, Sleep, and Youth Outcomes: A Meta-analysis - PubMed
The exercise snack helps students get started
What is impacted with exercise bouts: Before you ask a sleepy class to sit still and concentrate, get the big muscles moving. Start the day with five to seven minutes of brisk whole-body movement, with short bursts of harder effort and easier movement in between. In one school study, adolescents did ten minutes of short sprints and walking recoveries on one morning and rested on another. After exercise, they answered faster on a task that required them to ignore a distracting cue and choose the right response, with no loss of accuracy. The benefit was specific to that task. Working memory and visual search showed no clear improvement. This provides support to consider introducing movement before the first lesson, especially when the job in front of students is to tune out distractions and get started. Sprint-based exercise and cognitive function in adolescents - PubMed It should be appreciated that the positive results were task specific, that is, there was increased responsiveness and improved ability to filter out distractions, basically signs of alertness, but working memory and visual search showed no clear improvement.
Agitation? What about the student who’s already on edge? Ignoring a distracting cue on a test and letting a classmate’s comment go both ask a student to manage a response. The second adds emotion, social pressure and a judgment about what the other person meant. That’s where the evidence is thinner. A randomized crossover study in children looked at how a single bout of moderate exercise affected their response to a laboratory stressor. It tested a different kind of movement and a different outcome from what we’re proposing for the first period. The studies above give us a stronger basis for expecting a change in how students engage with the next task than for predicting fewer arguments or outbursts. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11868984
My reason for putting this at the start of the day is simple. That’s when we need students to shift from arriving at school to doing the first piece of work. Given we are asking young minds to start without the advantage of receiving a “get-going” shot of morning sunlight, we need to be innovative. Give them an active start. The exact five- to seven-minute routine still needs further testing in sleep-deficient junior high and high school students but the evidence is pointing toward a better outcome academically.